HomeAbout UsInaccurate Health ClaimsMisleading the PublicDiscrimination Against SmokersOutdoor Smoking BansGoing Too FarThe OrganizationsContact Us

Over the past decade, the tobacco control movement has been transformed from a truly grassroots, social movement into a highly centralized and institutionalized, money-driven movement. It has become increasingly focused on money and less concerned with scientific accuracy, clarity of public communications, and transparency to the public.

This page documents these changes by highlighting the tactics being used by a number of the major national anti-smoking organizations. While there are many smaller state and local groups that are also using questionable tactics, such as misleading the public about the science, the organizations highlighted on this page are particularly important because their actions set the tone for the entire movement and smaller groups take direction from them.

Our hope is that by highlighting the unethical, deceptive, hypocritical, or otherwise inappropriate actions of these groups and holding them publicly accountable for these actions, they will decide to change their behavior and to embrace the highest principles and standards of public health practice.

FallaciousClaims/trk.title.JPG

Misleading Campaign to Promote FDA Tobacco Legislation 

Why the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids' Campaign of Deception on the FDA Bill is So Unethical

Partners for Effective Tobacco Policy Coalition Sends Deceptive Letter to Congress

In Calling for FDA Legislation to Reduce Nicotine Addiction, Anti-Smoking Organization is Full of It; And Devoid of Integrity

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Continues to Deceive the American People on FDA Tobacco Legislation

Faith Leaders Appear to Be Hoodwinked by FDA Tobacco Legislation; Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids' Campaign of Deception Appears to Be Working

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Again Suggests that Big Tobacco Opposes FDA Tobacco Legislation; Misleading and Deceptive Propaganda is Unethical

More Misleading Claims Found in Tobacco-Free Kids' Campaign of Deception to Promote FDA Legislation

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Continues to Mislead the Public about Flawed FDA Bill; This Time, University of Minnesota Report is the Stimulus

Hypocrisy and Doublespeak: Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Attacks Tobacco Industry for Lobbying for Public Health Legislation

Deadline for Challenge to Tobacco-Free Kids Passes; Apparently, No Apology Nor Honesty Forthcoming

Why Anti-Smoking Campaign Dishonesty is Such a Problem and Why Tobacco-Free Kids is Largely Responsible

Where is the Honesty? Challenge Issued to Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids to Apologize for Misleading Constituents

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids' Public Opinion Poll Shows Widespread Support for FDA Tobacco Legislation, Or Does It? Junk Science Rears its Ugly Head

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Misleads the Public about FDA Legislation; Campaign of Deception Continues in Full Force

And Now for Something Completely Different: More Deception by the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Again Deceives Constituents About Philip Morris' Support for FDA Tobacco Legislation; Is TFK Even Capable of Honesty?

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Again Deceives Constituents about Philip Morris Support for FDA Legislation

Article Accuses Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids of Engaging in Secret Negotiations with Philip Morris; Outlines Numerous Flaws of FDA Tobacco Bill

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Again Deceives the Public About FDA Tobacco Legislation; Honesty is Apparently Not Possible

More Deception by Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids on FDA Legislation: Is a Candid Statement Even Possible for Them?

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Deceives Congress About Nature of Public Support for FDA Tobacco Legislation; Testimony Presents Junk Science

Inappropriate Use of Youths to Promote FDA Tobacco Legislation

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Manipulating Kids to Promote FDA Legislation

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids Misusing Kids to Promote Philip Morris' Legislative Agenda

Misusing Youths to Serve their Purposes: The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids and Ignite

 


FallaciousClaims/alf.title.JPG

Hypocrisy: Bemoaning Tobacco Advertising to Kids and Partnering With the Chief Culprit

American Legacy Foundation Partnering with Corporate Killer, By Its Own Admission

American Legacy Foundation Teams Up With Seventeen Magazine to Reduce Smoking (and with Numerous Other Magazines to Increase Smoking)

The Ultimate in Hypocrisy: Time Warner Corporate Partner Bemoans Smoking in Time Warner Movies

American Legacy Foundation Partners Bringing Glamorous Tobacco Messages to America's Young People

Anti-Smoking Groups Call On-Screen Smoking One of the Gravest Threats to Children; Legacy Asks Parents to Attack Legacy Partner

New Ad Reveals that American Legacy Foundation Partner has Delivered 10 Billion Tobacco Impressions to U.S. Theater Audiences

American Legacy Foundation Anti-Smoking Summer Tour to Begin

Weekly Update on Leader in Tobacco Control Movement: The Hearst Corporation

American Legacy Foundation Unwilling to Put Mouth Where Its Money Is

American Legacy Foundation Exposes Its Own Extreme Hypocrisy: Criticizes Smoking in Movies While Partnering with the Chief Culprit

American Legacy Foundation Admits Partnering with Company that is Knowingly Recruiting Multitudes of New Young Smokers

American Legacy Foundation Bemoans "Missed Opportunity" by DOJ to Help Smokers Quit

American Legacy Foundation Partner Helping Promote Smokeless Tobacco to Smokers

American Legacy Foundation Issues Recommendations to Reduce Youth Exposure to Smoking in the Movies

American Legacy Foundation Releases Recommendations to Counter Youth Exposure to Smoking in Movies; Forgets Most Important One

Public Health Groups Attack New Cigarette Ads, Fail to Reveal Public Health Corporate Partner of One Company that is Carrying the Ads

Weekly Update on Leader in Tobacco Control Movement: Time Inc.

American Legacy Foundation Honors Top Tobacco Ad Publisher

Failure to Disclose Conflicts of Interest; Formation of Front Group

American Legacy Foundation Tactics to Increase its Funding Exposed

American Legacy Foundation Again Fails to Disclose Conflict of Interest in Citing Research on Effectiveness of Itself

American Legacy Foundation Praises Itself; Pays Front Group to Praise Itself

Adweek Article Suggests that Legacy-Funded Commission Exists Primarily to Seek Funding for Legacy

Citizens' Commission to Protect the Truth Files Amicus Brief in DOJ Tobacco Lawsuit

Citizens' Commission Asks Judge Kessler for Inquisition into Remedy Change; Again Fails to Disclose Conflict of Interest

Citizens' Commission Still Not Revealing the Truth; How Can It Be Expected to Protect the Truth?

Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids and Other Interveners Disclose Conflict of Interest in Post-Trial Brief; Sharp Contrast with Citizens' Commission

Citizens' Commission to Protect the Truth is Hiding the Truth


FallaciousClaims/anr.title.JPG

Misleading, Premature, and Irresponsible Political Attacks 
 

Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights Defends its Unqualified Claim that Associate Attorney General Robert McCallum is a Former Tobacco Industry Lawyer

McCallum Cleared of Misconduct; ANR and Other Anti-Smoking Groups’ Political Attacks Were Irresponsible and Unjustified

After Lots of Fanfare, McCallum Deposition Turns Up Nothing

DOJ Tobacco Ruling Demonstrates that McCallum Did Not Destroy or Undermine Government's Case; Anti-Smoking Groups Were Wrong

Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights Still Deceiving American Public

Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights Apparently Decides to Retain Misleading Website Information

ANR Apparently Admits Mistake in Deception of Public About Robert McCallum

On McCallum and Conflict of Interest in DOJ Lawsuit: An Analysis

Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights (ANR) Should Stick to Public Health, Not Political Attacks and Smear Campaigns

Misleading Health Claims about Secondhand Smoke 

Another Anti-Smoking Group Makes Fallacious Scientific Claims in Support of Smoking Bans

New Study Shows that Coronary Blood Flow is Not Impaired in Active Smokers, Much Less Passive Smokers; Statements of 38+ Anti-Smoking Groups are False

At Least 38 Health and Anti-Smoking Groups are Misleading the Public by Conflating Coronary Blood Flow and Coronary Flow Velocity Reserve

Anti-Smoking Groups Using Misleading Scientific Statements to Support Smoking Bans

Blowing Secondhand Smoke: New Research Uncovers False Claims Spread by Anti-Smoking Groups

The Science Doesn't Matter: Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights Fails to Defend or Correct Its False Claims About Acute Cardiovascular Effects of ETS

New Study Shows McDonalds Meal Causes Same Degree of Endothelial Dysfunction as Brief Tobacco Smoke Exposure; Anti-Smoking Groups' Claims are Flawed

Moment of Truth for Americans for Nonsmokers' Rights Has Arrived

Undocumented Claims about Opponents   

Despite Lack of Evidence, ANR Again Accuses FORCES of Being A Big Tobacco Front Group

FORCES International: Tobacco Industry Front Group?

IN MY VIEW: Show Us the Evidence - Time for ANR to Document FORCES' Tobacco Industry Funding or Remove it from its Website

ANR-Proclaimed Big Tobacco Front Group/Ally Helps Lay Path to Bring Down Big Tobacco's Master Settlement

Challenge to Provide Documentation that FORCES is a Tobacco Front Group Ends; Anti-Smoking Groups Should Cease from Making Such Claims

Brainwashing in the Anti-Smoking Movement: #1 - Smearing the Opposition

Deception of the Public 

ANR Again Massively Deceives its Constituents

ANR Once Again Deceives Its Constituents

ANR Quickly Changes its Tune to Meet Political Ends

Why Anti-Smoking Groups Misleading the Public is Such a Problem